What the examiners said In Australia, a thesis must be submitted to three examiners: The comments are sent back to the examinations committee, who decide whether the candidate's thesis is Acceptable as-is uncommon Acceptable with minor revisions most common, and what I got Acceptable only with major additional work and re-submission. Here is the bulk of the examiners' comments on the submitted version of my thesis.
I contemplated answering in characters or less, but I wanted to avoid writing a journal article, so I volunteered a blog post instead.
Actually, that might have been Socrates talking about life, but my point remains the same. So — who should it be? In the USA research students are lucky enough to be Thesis examiner report by their supervisors or maybe not so lucky, as this piece from My Grad School suggestsbut in other places examination is a peer review process.
In Australia the viva an oral presentation to examiners who have already read the text is rare. We are a long way from anywhere and flying examiners in is prohibitively expensive. Thesis examination is an object of study and researchers agree that the choice of thesis examiners needs to be handled with extreme care.
Examiners are human and will bring their own pet likes and dislikes into the process of reading your work. At RMIT, and many other places, the student does not choose the examiners — the supervisor does.
Some supervisors are very open about discussing potential examiners with the student; others take the rules very seriously and refuse to even discuss it. If the latter is the case for you I recommend taking the initiative and broaching the subject anyway as you do have the right to say who should not be examining.
Only those who have been immersed in similar topics will be qualified to judge your work. Your supervisor may not be reading the same sorts of literature and may be unaware of who is out there — so help them out.
The easiest way is to make an examiners profile. Make a list of your five favourite academic writers within your topic domain and Google stalk them. Use this information to write a short 2 or 3 page document for your supervisor. Include names and short profiles of each person you have chosen as well as your rationale for why they would be a good examiner.
Include contact details including university affiliation, address, phone number and email details.
Give this examiner profile document to your supervisor at least six months before you plan to submit which should coincide with the first full draft of your thesis. Finally please — listen to Aunty Thesis Whisperer now — keep a copy of the email with the date stamp. Is there something that should be number five on the list?
Alternatively, do you have any questions about examination? Pop them in the comments!Thesis examination is an object of study and researchers agree that the choice of thesis examiners needs to be handled with extreme care.
Examiners are human and will bring their own pet likes and dislikes into the process of reading your work. Phd Thesis Examiner Report. phd thesis examiner report PhD thesis quality: The views of examiners of Newcastle. Australia 1 Stellenbosch University, information is the content of the written examiner report61 thoughts on “ 4 things you should know about choosing examiners for a PhD thesis but you should know about choosing examiners for your thesis What examiners do: what.
BECE Chief Examiner's Report for Pre-Technical Skills by Research and Thesis Support.
June 08, GENERAL COMMENTS The standard of the paper compared favourably with that of previous years and it was within the scope of the syll GENERAL COMMENTS. Each examiner is required to submit a detailed independent report together with a completed summary recommendation regardbouddhiste.comers are asked to address both the strengths and weaknesses of the thesis or exegesis and creative work and to provide detailed comments about the overall quality of the.
Examiners are requested to (i) write a thesis assessment report, and (ii) make their thesis assessment recommendation on form DRC Following receipt of all three thesis . Examiners The PhD thesis is examined by three examiners who are people with standing in the field of study.
One Please do not include the recommendation in your report on the thesis, as this is released to the candidate. Instead, use the enclosed Examiners Recommendation Form.