The effect of publish or perish

However, incentive and reward systems in academia were considered to lead a publish or perish syndrome by keeping the academic staff under pressure Bloom et al. On the one hand, these systems lead to a an increase in the quantity of books and papers Bloom et al. As it is seen, these yester have both advantageous and disadvantageous.

The effect of publish or perish

Share via Email Acupuncture research showing a 'tiny and erratic effect' was published in a leading GP journal accompanied by a glowing press release.

It doesn't work very well any more, mainly as a result of the enormous number of papers that are being published an estimated 1. There simply aren't enough competent people to do the job.

Why ‘publish or perish’? Why not ‘publish and prosper’? Perspectives from developing countries

The overwhelming effect of the huge and unpaid effort that is put into reviewing papers is to maintain a status hierarchy of journals. Any paper, however bad, can now get published in a journal that claims to be peer-reviewed.


The blame for this sad situation lies with the people who have imposed a publish-or-perish culture, namely research funders and senior people in universities. To have "written" papers is regarded as something to boast about rather than being rather shameful.

University PR departments encourage exaggerated claims, and hard-pressed authors go along with them. Not long ago, Imperial College's medicine department were told that their "productivity" target for publications was to "publish three papers per annum including one in a prestigious journal with an impact factor of at least five.

The only people who benefit from the intense pressure to publish are those in the publishing industry. Hardly a day passes without a new journal starting.

The effect of publish or perish

My email inbox is full of invitations to publish in a weird variety of journals. They'll take just about anything. They are all "peer-reviewed", but rarely publish anything worth reading.

The peer review for a journal on homeopathy is, presumably, done largely by other believers in magic. If that were not the case, these journals would soon vanish. But it isn't only quack journals that have failures in peer review.

In June, the British Journal of General Practice published a paper, " Acupuncture for 'frequent attenders' with medically unexplained symptoms: It has lots of numbers, but the result is very easy to see.

All you have to do is look at their Figure.

Related topics

A figure accompanying an acupuncture research paper. BJGP It's obvious at a glance that acupuncture has at best a tiny and erratic effect on any of the outcomes that were measured.

The results are indeed quite interesting because they show that acupuncture doesn't even have a perceptible placebo effect. But this is not what the authors said.publish or perish Getting favourable papers published in journals is seen as a sound marketing strategy by drug companies.

Ghost written editorials and review papers to promote off-label use of drugs is commonplace.

Response on behalf of the CACTUS Study research team

The pressure to publish as evidence of an individual's performance has steadily increased. In the characteristic late twentieth century western world, specifically in the American scenario, the dictum ‘publish or perish’ gained ground, reaching axiomatic relevance. > The Effect of Publish or Perish Motto on Academics The Effect of Publish or Perish Motto on Academics These systems present in most universities acknowledge publications and citations as the evidence Of scholarly achievement and necessity for promotion, grant, and tenure (Dark, ).

Aug 28,  · For reasons unknown, Semmelweis had always refused to publish his results or even to deliver public lectures. He was eventually convinced to write a book, The Etiology, Concept, and Prophylaxis of Childbed Fever.

If you’re a professor, you’re no stranger to the term “publish or perish.” And for good reason. The publish or perish phenomenon has been around since when consistent publication became the golden performance metric of successful professors.

Publish or perish" is a phrase coined to describe the pressure in academia to rapidly and continually publish academic work to sustain or further one's career.

[1] [2] [3] Frequent publication is one of the few methods at scholars' disposal to demonstrate academic talent.

Publish or Perish: What are its Consequences? - Enago Academy